Definitive guide to Mattress Cover – Mattress Protector 6

What is the use of a mattress protector?

Mattress protectors are essential elements in the lasting relationship between owner and mattress, making both their existences much easier to bear.

For example, if the mattress you recently acquired is somewhat shiny, your sheet will move around as you move around, which is entirely unpleasant.

A mattress protector is tightly wrapped around the mattress itself and is usually made of cotton, mixed with polyester, ensuring that it not only stretches enough to encompass the entire mattress, it also stays put and keeps your sheets in place.

Also, mattresses are known to be fertile ground for all sorts of allergens and for getting dirty very quickly. It’s incredibly useful to have a mattress protector, since it forms a barrier between the allergens and your sensitive skin or nose and it keeps the mattress nice and clean.

Here they are:

PictureModelMy Overall Quality RatingSee Amazon Offer
SureGuard Mattress ProtectorSureGuard Mattress Protector5 / 5ratings
Cool Shield No Allergy Waterproof Mattress ProtectorCool Shield No Allergy Waterproof Mattress Protector4.8 / 5ratings
Luna Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress ProtectorLuna Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector4.9 / 5ratings
Hanna Kay Premium Waterproof Mattress ProtectorHanna Kay Premium 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector5 / 5ratings
Sleep Tite by Malouf Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress ProtectorSleep Tite by Malouf Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector4.9 / 5ratings
SafeRest Premium Waterproof Lab Certified Bed Bug Proof Zippered Mattress EncasementSafeRest Premium Mattress Encasement5 / 5ratings

Most appreciated brands

Now, you can make your own mattress protector at home or at you can have one made the tailor’s, but it will have limited use.

If your mattress is to be used only indoors and only on certain occasions, then that home – made or custom – made cover is good enough, but if you travel with your mattress or if you go camping with it, you need a professionally made mattress protector. I

t’s a big market out there for all sorts of mattress related gear, but some have never failed me, like Protect-A-Bed, which makes waterproof mattress protectors, Hanna Kay, on the middle range of prices and Linen Collection, on the low, but still pretty darn good quality, end.


Mattresses and allergies

The important thing to remember whenever you buy any kind of sleeping equipment, be it a mattress, a bed frame, sheets, pillows or duvets is that you need to keep in mind whatever it is that you are allergic to.

For example, if you have a mattress that is made of a blend of cotton and polyester on the surface, chances are that it is going to get dirty, especially on the polyester sides, which is rather unfortunate, since those are the ones that are hard to clean. No matter how much you try, once you get the plastic part dirty, microbes and all sorts of allergens, like dust, pollen, small pieces of feathers or bed bugs, will always be stuck between the fibers.

On the other hand, excessive cleaning of your mattress will also result in you developing allergies or triggering the ones you already have.

Since you can’t really use normal detergent to wash mattresses, you need to gently clean them with some soap and hot water, Some people get rashes from liquid soap, but it’s not like you can get a bar of soap and just go to town on your mattress.

If you do use a mattress protector, which you really should, since it limits the times you need to thoroughly clean your mattress, do wash it with the rest of your linens, using the same type of detergent that doesn’t give you allergies.

If you experiment with different cleaning products for different things, you might end up also introducing yourself to a lot of new antihistaminic drugs.

What are the most important features to look for when buying a mattress cover?

Well, for starters, you need to be really sure why you need a mattress cover.

If you buy one for your indoor use, outdoor use or camping use, the features are completely different. The basic things when talking about a good to excellent quality cover are the followings: the material it’s made of must be in complete agreement with your usage of the mattress, the method of attaching the mattress protector to the mattress must ensure it stays put in every and all circumstances and the stain removal should be a fairly simple process.

Basically, an excellent protector should be made of the right material, it should not budge easily and it must be washable.

Therefore, watch out for cotton covers when using the mattress only indoor and for ones made of stronger fibers when taking it camping in rough terrain.

The mattress protector can be made of both cotton and some sort of plastic when you keep your mattress in your backyard and get yourself a tan on it.

Don’t buy a lightly colored cover in any case, unless you actually just sleep on the mattress, because it will get dirty quite quickly.

If you choose a mattress cover that has an elastic band, make sure that the band itself is flexible enough and it stretches enough so as to fit your mattress comfortably.

You don’t want it unsnapping and leaving you sleeping on the mattress itself. However, if you prefer a zippered one, that shouldn’t be a problem. Of course, check the zipper on its entire length before buying the cover.

Materials used

The materials used for making mattress protectors are not all that varied, but then again, they really don’t need to be, since using a cover for your mattress is really not a question of style, but rather one of practicality.

Therefore, cotton is best used for mattress protectors that need to be firm, dense and hypoallergenic and polyester is considered to be the inexpensive, but solid version. Of course, a blend of both cotton and polyester works best for most people, since it means that the cover is both hypoallergenic and durable.

If you have moisture issues when using your mattress, perhaps you would prefer a vinyl cover, which is not as comfortable as the others, but it does keep the mattress perfectly dry.

Best mattress protector

When you want to buy the best protector for you mattress that the market has to offer, it can set you back quite a pretty penny, if you base your shopping decisions on the price tag.

However, as many of us know, the most expensive product out there is not necessarily the best one and here are five examples that prove the above theory right:

SureGuard Mattress ProtectorSureGuard Mattress Protector (Amazon link): it is everything that a mattress cover should be, but mainly it is completely hypoallergenic. It comes in five sizes, the most sought after being the queen one, although all types are made of organic cotton, which ensures the fact that they are going to be safe to use even for extremely sensitive persons or for babies. The SureGuard Mattress Protector is waterproof, keeping any sort of wetness away from your mattress and it can be washed at home, along with all your other clothes and with the same kind of detergent. It has elastic on all sides, making it easy to put on a mattress and really excellent at staying there, no matter how much you move around. On the downside, buying this particular mattress cover will set you back about fifty dollars.

Cool Shield No Allergy Waterproof Mattress ProtectorCool Shield No Allergy Waterproof Mattress Protector (Amazon link): unlike the one above, the Cool Shield is not completely made of cotton, but rather of 80% cotton and 20% polyester, which makes is a bit more stretchable and somewhat less hypoallergenic. You see, while it does claim to be breathable and to protect both the mattress and the owner from dust mites, molds and allergens and it does perform rather well, there are people that have reported severe allergies due to the polyester. Normally, it retails for about a hundred dollars, which is rather steep for its performance capabilities, but you can find it discounted at times, even at a third of the price.

Luna Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress ProtectorLuna Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector (Amazon link) –  the two most important things about a waterproof mattress protector are its waterproof layer and its ability to mold perfectly to any shape and size of your mattress. This particular mattress protector does both excellently, with the added bonus that it is very noiseless. You see, there are some waterproof layers that, while efficient, are really loud. Which is not a good thing, if you consider using the mattress cover for a mattress in your baby’s crib or even in your own bedroom. The Luna mattress protector is also completely hypoallergenic, being made of organic cotton and, just like any other high quality cover, it can be washed at home. However, the excellent waterproof layer can work against it: some buyers claim they wake up drenched in sweat in the warmer months, simply because the mattress cover won’t allow the moisture to seep to the mattress itself.

Hanna Kay Premium Waterproof Mattress ProtectorHanna Kay Premium 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector (Amazon link) – it is among the most affordable high quality mattress protectors out there. However, it comes in only four sizes, not including a double twin mattress cover, which is quite popular with a lot of college students. Unlike others, the Hanna Kay mattress protector actually has different widths, making it useful for both thin and thick mattresses, as well as any other ones in between. It allows you to feel your mattress, due to its very thin, albeit very sound, structure and it is breathable, which ensures that you won’t wake up all sweaty and hot.

Sleep Tite by Malouf Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress ProtectorSleep Tite by Malouf Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector (Amazon link) – this cover comes with a steep price and a fifteen year guarantee. Is that a good thing or a bad thing? Well, truly, it is not all that different from a normal, ten year guarantee, mattress cover. Even more so, a lot of customers have complained that the process of making use of your guarantee is not worth the hassle, as in many cases, the buyer is to blame for damaging the mattress cover. It does function and has the same qualities as any other cotton – made, hypoallergenic, waterproof mattress protector, but it is not worth spending more than one hundred dollars on it.

Best mattress cover

SafeRest Premium Waterproof Lab Certified Bed Bug Proof Zippered Mattress EncasementThere are a lot of mattress covers out there, made of all sorts of materials, useful for all sorts of things and available at every price imaginable. However, out of all of these, the SafeRest Premium Mattress Encasement  (Amazon link) is the best one. Made of organic cotton, it is essentially the standard in hypoallergenic mattress protectors, while still being considered one of the most luxurious on the market today. It can be washed at home, with your normal laundry, which is always a plus. What makes it waterproof? Well, it has an underside made of a waterproof material. Quite simple, if you think about it. The originality of this particular mattress protector is the fact that your body never comes into contact with the waterproof part, which ensures that your allergies will not be easily triggered.  Also, it has an elastic edge, making it fairly secure once you get it on and it contains no PVC and no phthalate derivates, something that not many mattress covers out there can claim.

Before buying – quick tips

1. Where are you going to use your mattress and, subsequently, your mattress cover?

This is an essential question you need to answer before going and spending a pretty penny on the ultimate mattress protector. If you plan on keeping the mattress inside the house at all times, then a cotton, hypoallergenic, waterproof but breathable cover is the one you should go for. However, if you think on going camping, a vinyl cover is more suited to your needs.

2. Do you want the cover to be fitted, to have elastic on its sides or to be zippered?

It’s all about the usage you want to get from it. So, if you’re an adult that uses the mattress for sleeping on it, you could get a fitted cover, since chances are that you’re not going to toss and turn so much as to get it loose. However, if you want to use it for your children’s bedrooms, elastic is the way to go. Kids tend to move around a lot and the fitted cover will most surely come undone. The zippered version is usually only employed by the vinyl covers, since they must envelop the entire mattress and keep it from getting dirty and wet.

3. How much money do you want to spend?

This is an important question, since it determines the quality of the mattress cover you are going to get. Normally, excellent mattress covers run from 80 dollars to 120 dollars, but you could wait for the moments when they are discounted, since they go down almost two thirds of their original price. Don’t buy a cheap one to start with because you will get your money’s worth and buying multiple inexpensive ones will turn out to cost more than a better quality one.

4. What width is your mattress?

Most owners never take this into considerations and they end up with mattress covers that are either too thick or too thin and that do not fit perfectly on their mattresses. Measure the width of the mattress and buy a cover that fits. Keep in mind that it must not fit inch per inch, it should be a bit bigger than your mattress.

5. White or color?

Here is the problem with colors in mattress covers: they might seep into other laundry. However, if you need a protector for the mattress in your children’s room, color is the way to go. It keeps the kids entertained and relaxed and it hides spots and dirty patches. You should go white only in guest rooms or your own bedroom, if you feel adventurous.

The following two tabs change content below.

James Menta

Camping Gear Reviewer at
Three things you need to know about James - he holds a degree in Materials Technology from the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, he is a zealot for the great outdoors and he can never find his glasses.       In brief intermissions between looking for his glasses, he is the Editor-in-chief of

6 thoughts on “Definitive guide to Mattress Cover – Mattress Protector

  1. Reply Void Oct 19,2015 7:07 pm

    One thing I have trouble with on air mattresses is that they are cold at night in cold weather (never really noticed anything in warm weather). Will these take care of that or will I still need to put down stuff for insulation so I can get a nice cozy foam-like sleep?

    • Reply James Dec 18,2015 12:10 pm

      Void, that’s one of the most common complaints and also one that’s easily solved, either by getting some of the toppers (listed in the guide above) or a simple thick blanket under the sheets. The blanket is the budget friendly option, but a topper is a permanent solution and if I might add, a solution that will get rid of the feeling of the blanket wrinkling under the sheets (which I personally can’t stand)…


  2. Reply Mason Sep 14,2015 5:04 pm

    great article. Another great protective option is Protect Ease. That’s what I use and they are great.

    • Reply James N Sep 21,2015 9:25 am

      Thanks for the kind words Mason. I don’t know much about the brand you mentioned but thanks for sharing.

      My best

  3. Reply Vinny Mar 24,2015 3:20 pm

    Awesome guide! Another thing to take into consideration when choosing between a zippered or elastic protector is bed bugs. Elastic protectors won’t keep them out, but zippered protectors completely encase the bed, so they can

Leave a Reply